#FreeStacy: Twitter Banning Has Free Speech, 1st Amendment Implications

#FreeStacy: Twitter Banning Has Free Speech, 1st Amendment Implications

#FreeStacy: Twitter Banning Has Free Speech, 1st Amendment Implications

Ahhhh Twitter!! Such an interesting social media site it is! Where else can you watch Twitter tantrums by Donald Trump? Where else can you track accounts that showcase the beheading and terror horrors that is ISIS, or the accounts by those in Iran who, if you pay close enough attention and have even a remote grasp on reality – you’d see that Iran really and truly hates us – Deal or No Deal.

tech-twitter-generic-2

In other words, Twitter is THE place to have your say in 140 characters or less! Free Speech at its finest RIGHT?? Well….it was. Until this happened:

On Friday, Twitter suspended the account of Robert Stacy McCain, a conservative blogger and dogged critic of feminism, apparently without warning or explanation. This has led, in true Twitter fashion, to protests under the hashtag #FreeStacy.

Yes, that’s right. Stacy McCain’s Twitter account was arbitrarily suspended. To date he’s received zero communication from Twitter as to what was so heinous about his tweets or account that would lead to such a suspension. Keep in mind that in some ways, heck in many ways, Stacy is a polarizing creature. He is blunt – sometimes REALLY REALLY blunt about his views. Yet somehow he’s managed to attract around 80,000 followers on Twitter.

18506_UYoMec8A

In my opinion it’s because he’s a take no prisoners kind of guy when it comes to defending this country, the Constitution, expressing his extreme disgust for political correctness and what passes for feminism these days. Do I always agree with what he’s said or tweeted? Heck no! Do I get my shorts in such a knot that I demand his account be banned. Nope – I like to think I’m grownup enough and realistic enough to decide when or if I want to engage or just walk away. Unfortunately, that doesn’t seem the case for a certain group within the Twitter corporation.

Remember a few days ago, when Twitter elevated anti-GamerGate leader Anita Sarkeesian to its “Trust and Safety Council,” an imperious-sounding committee with Robespierre-esque powers to police discussion on the social media platform? The goal, according to Twitter, was to make it easier for users to express themselves freely and safely.

Is it just me or does the title Trust and Safety Council have a rather dictatorial ring to it? Here’s something else to keep in mind regarding this “council.”

Only a few weeks earlier, Twitter had announced the creation of a “Trust and Safety Council,” to which it appointed Anita Sarkeesian, a feminist known for denouncing “sexism” in video games, a prominent figure in the Gamergate controversy—and oh yes, a frequent target of criticism from McCain. So it sure looks like the moment Twitter gave Sarkeesian the power to do so, she started blackballing her critics.

Things that make you go HMMMMMM. So what happened next? The #FreeStacy hashtag started trending in a huge way on Friday night. For a little while anyway…

And that’s the thing… it looks highly suspicious that Twitter is playing favorites and games behind the scenes. In fact many are pointing that out via Twitter, Facebook, and even Youtube.

Reason’s Robby Soave points out that Twitter can certainly do what they want to keep their brand strong and their customer base happy

As of today, Stacy no longer has any Twitter accounts associated with him live and active.

And therein lies the rub.

08282fcbdc33f0bb98110876a70608bc_400x400

Two accounts have been banned and neither Twitter nor its creepy Orwellian Trust And Safety Council of watchers are forthcoming with an explanation as to what exactly landed him into hot water. Yet we are supposed to believe this from Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey?

  • “Twitter stands for freedom of expression,”:   I guess that all depends upon what the definition of acceptable is.
  • “speaking truth to power,”: Am I not the only one that is experiencing a 60’s protest movement flashback with that phrase?
  • “and empowering dialogue.”:  Great! On whose terms and what criteria?
  • “That starts with safety.”:  Safety for whom? Who will be determining what speech, what freedom of expression, and what dialogue is safe? Who is deciding the guidelines and criteria for this particular type of “safety” for free speech?

united-states-constitution

In establishing this Trust and Safety Council it seems disturbingly evident that Twitter has forgotten the very meaning of the word freedom. They’ve forgotten that the success of their platform is because of Freedom of Speech. If Twitter continues on this path of arbitrarily removing someone’s right to free speech because someone else wasn’t feeling “safe,” due to the dissenting opinion expressed; then I can only suppose that the company is no longer a fan of anyone’s 1st Amendment rights to Free Speech… including their own.

Written by

11 Comments
  • Joe Miller says:

    I just deactivated my Twitter account. I’m tired of this crap.

  • GWB says:

    It will become the 140-character journalist – the only people on it will be those who want to be in the echo chamber.

  • GWB says:

    I do have a somewhat silly question….

    Why didn’t they just name it The Committee For Public Safety?

    • Jodi Giddings says:

      Or how about Brown Shirts for Safe Spaces. At least then they’d be telling us the truth.

      • Jodi Giddings says:

        BTW: I’ve had endless leftists tell me to “go shoot yourself with those guns you love so much,” etc etc. I’ve reported them to Twitter, and not one time has any of them been suspended. Not. Once.

      • GWB says:

        Most of them aren’t historically literate enough to know what the Committee is. Some of them may actually be proud to be on that board.

        But yours is a very appropriate moniker, as well. 🙂

    • Nina says:

      I’ve had various similar definitions running through my head since I saw that oh so cutesy committee title. But when its accompanied by historical flashbacks to various “committees” that emanated from places such as the USSR and Germany pre & during WWII… I get very very uneasy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe
Become a Victory Girl!

Are you interested in writing for Victory Girls? If you’d like to blog about politics and current events from a conservative POV, send us a writing sample here.
Ava Gardner
gisonboat
rovin_readhead