University of Michigan Spins for Gun Control

University of Michigan Spins for Gun Control

University of Michigan Spins for Gun Control

University of Michigan researchers posted a disturbing study a few days ago in an obvious attempt to whip up emotions about children and firearm homicides. The team calculates that roughly 8 children per day die in firearms incidents.

This is indeed a disturbing statistic, and the researchers, of course, use it to call for more gun control.

U-M firearm injury prevention researcher and emergency physician Patrick Carter, M.D., assistant director of the Injury Prevention Center, co-authored the study.

“Firearm risk to children and adolescents, whether from unintentional or intentional use of a gun, is a serious medical issue that all of us in the profession can help address,” he says. “The results from this study certainly have inspired me as a physician to know that we need to be doing better. We hope that these findings will also encourage other physicians to know that this is indeed their ‘lane’ to be working in, to be preventing firearm related injury and death.”

Courtesy of Twitter

Note the reference to “their lane” in Carter’s little diatribe, referencing the recent spat between doctors and the NRA in which medical professionals got so angry at the NRA’s reference to their lack of policy knowledge and the organization’s advice to “stay in their lane” that they started posting bloody photos on the Internet, literally bathing in the blood of their patients to push a political agenda!

This gives us an idea of where the good Dr. Carter stands on the issue of firearm violence.

I also note that the article in Medical Press that I cited above doesn’t delve into the actual numbers, but rather – when possible – refers to the victims aged 1-19 as “children.”

Meanwhile, firearms—the number two cause of death in youth—claimed the lives of more than 3,140 children and teens in 2016, according to the new findings from a University of Michigan team.

That’s about eight children a day, according to their special report in the New England Journal of Medicine.

First of all, people aged 18-19 are not “children.” They are legally adults who can serve in the military, purchase some weapons, live on their own, have jobs, etc. When these medical professionals classify them as “children” for the purpose of fomenting hysteria about “gun violence,” they’re being disingenuous and undermining their own credibility.

When adults ages 18-19 are taken out of the equation, the number of children who died in “gun violence,” according to the CDC, is 1,637. According to the CDC, 7 of those 1,637 were legal interventions, such as police actions or self defense, which brings the number to 1,630.

Tragically 633 – or 38.8 percent – were suicides. This is heartbreaking, but as we discussed previously, no law would fix this, and banning firearms outright would likely not alter this statistic, judging by the fact that Japan’s suicide rate is massively higher than ours, and gun ownership is all but banned there.

This leaves 997 children who died from homicides, accidents, and undetermined causes in 2016.

But let’s look a bit further.

Of those, 862 deaths were homicides. Breaking it down by age, 196 kids ages 0-13 – or 22.7 percent – were killed in 2016. The remainder were kids ages 14-17. Would you care to guess what the prime age for gang involvement is in the United States?

According to government statistics, 34 percent of youth gang members are between the ages of 15 and 17. The NIH in 2010 determined that ” The prevalence of youth gang membership was 2.0% (1.2%-2.8%), peaking at age 14 years at 5.0% (3.9%-6.0%).”

Youth gang members were disproportionately male, black, Hispanic, from single-parent households, and families living below the poverty level. We estimated that there were 1,059,000 youth gang members in the United States in 2010 (bounds ranging from 675,000 to 1,535,000).

Is it any wonder that homicides in this age group are so prevalent?

Look, we absolutely need to focus on reducing violence – whether by firearm or another method – and these deaths are especially tragic when there is a young person involved. But lying, or at the very least twisting facts, in order to achieve a desired political outcome is not helpful.

Earlier this year, CNN and gun control groups lied about the number of school shootings – lies so egregious and easily debunked, that even left-leaning PolitiFact had to call “foul.” One has to wonder what kind of drooling ignorami believe this reporting, because this “research” into gun violence against children is absurd and easily refuted by simply looking at the CDC statistics. The attempts to mislead are not just obvious – they’re hamhanded and indicative of a desperate attempt to push “gun violence” as a nationwide issue, when it has become quite obvious that this is not what Americans care about.

In the first survey after the midterm Congressional election, mentions of immigration and healthcare as the top problems facing the country are down. Sixteen percent of Americans cite immigration as the top problem, down from 21% last month, while those noting healthcare dropped to 5% from 11%. One in five Americans, 19%, now say some aspect of the federal government is the top problem facing the U.S., little changed from the 18% who said the same last month. Americans were more likely to cite the government as the most important problem facing the U.S. than any other issue.

The problem is not guns. It has never been guns. It’s lack of a cohesive family unit. It’s gang activity. It’s a sense of desperation. Doctors need to stop advocating for Band-Aid solutions and start working to find fixes for the underlying problems that are the root of violence, be it gun or otherwise.

Featured photo by Oleg Volk (cropped).

Written by

Marta Hernandez is an immigrant, writer, editor, science fiction fan (especially military sci-fi), and a lover of freedom, her children, her husband and her pets. She loves to shoot, and range time is sacred, as is her hiking obsession, especially if we’re talking the European Alps. She is an avid caffeine and TWD addict, and wants to own otters, sloths, wallabies, koalas, and wombats when she grows up.

20 Comments
  • David Lentz says:

    There are far more guns in the country than their are physicians. Yet physicians kill eight times as many as do firearms, and most firearm deaths are suicide. So rather lobbying to further restrict firearms, first the doctors should heal themselves.

  • GWB says:

    Firearm risk […] is a serious medical issue
    No, it isn’t. Bleeding out from a gunshot wound might be a medical issue, but the use and misuse of firearms is NOT a medical issue.

    they’re being disingenuous
    They’re LYING.

    Once again, supposed “experts” think that, because of their knowledge in one arena, that they should be listened to on everything because they are just so much smarter than all us rubes.
    Warning: You are not as smart as you likely think you are.

  • That doctors are knowledgeable and experienced in treating trauma such as gunshot wounds does not make them experts, or even particularly well informed, on the societal problems of violence and how particular government policies might alleviate, or not, that problem. Claiming such expertise, saying “it is their lane” is fallacious reasoning at best. Adding in nonsense like calling 18 and 19 year old adults “children” just indicates that the fallacy is deliberate and removes any “well intentioned” benefit of the doub.

    https://thewriterinblack.com/2018/11/14/this-is-my-lane/

    • GWB says:

      And, given the lack of critical thinking it demonstrates, it might make you question their judgment relating to their actual area of supposed expertise, too.

  • MikeyParks says:

    When you have to lie to make your point, you have no point.

  • Brian Brandt says:

    I wouldn’t want to meet some of those ‘children’ in a dark alley.

  • Random Geek says:

    The doctors are precisely as credible on firearms policy as the NRA would be on what procedures to use to reduce deaths by medical malpractice.

    I would LOVE to see the NRA weigh in, and listen to the doctors squealing.

  • Epador says:

    The most disconnect is when they push the doctor questioning about firearms in the home. There is not one iota of evidence that such intrusion affects gun violence and deaths. Not one. But they push it with religious fervor.

  • Dennis says:

    I remember the significant decrease in all crimes when New York City stopped ignoring the little things (like turnstile jumping and windshield cleaners). More cops and especially more active cops combined with judges doling proper justice would work a million times better than arms banning. But it isn’t compatible with the altruists and is another failing of liberalism.

  • Andrew C Frechtling says:

    And would someone buy that cute little girl with the pink AR some eyes and ears?

    • Marta Hernandez says:

      That “cute little girl” is the now-21 year old daughter of science fiction author Michael Z. Williamson. And if you know anything at all about Mike, you’d know she has every bit of equipment possible to ensure her safety and skill. Photographer Oleg Volk was doing a photo shoot with her here, IIRC. No need for eyes and ears for that.

  • Bill G says:

    But, but, but if they fix the problem they won’t have to issue available to push people in the direction they want people to go!

  • Kzen says:

    Wait for the response, but everyone is someone’s child…

    The gun control zealots have been using misinformation and the bit about classifying 18 and 19 year olds as children for decades. Common tactic in the 90’s when discussing their various disarmament schemes.

  • Bob Heydt says:

    A friend of mines 15 year old daughter has a chrome plated 12 gauge shotgun that she’s been using for years. She can actually out shoot her dad. Last I heard from him, next on her list will be a 30-06 rifle for deer hunting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe
Become a Victory Girl!

Are you interested in writing for Victory Girls? If you’d like to blog about politics and current events from a conservative POV, send us a writing sample here.
Ava Gardner
gisonboat
rovin_readhead
Instagram