Dear Gen Z: We Need To Talk About Israel And Hamas

Dear Gen Z: We Need To Talk About Israel And Hamas

Dear Gen Z: We Need To Talk About Israel And Hamas

Gather around, young people. Or people of any age, really, but this conversation is going to be directed (mostly) at those of you who are of the “Gen Z” age group. We need to talk about war, why Israel has to fight, why Hamas must lose, and the nature of evil.

Now, I do know something about Gen Z – after all, my kids are all within the Gen Z age range, with two of them now legal adults. For us older generations (I’m a late Gen Xer myself), Gen Z is the age range out there on college campuses, chanting slogans, and not comprehending that their speech is so racist and abhorrent (and in the case of Patrick Dai, allegedly escalated to death threats) that their future employment prospects are now on the line. After years of “politically correct” curriculum shoved down their throats, and the idea that being an “ally” is more important than having knowledge, and being wise enough to determine right from wrong, Gen Z is now falling flat on their faces because they fail to grasp certain realities. The same group that wants to proclaim “my truth” doesn’t want to look actual facts in the eye, and discover that they might have been wrong all along.

So, Gen Z, let’s have a conversation about the facts, and then I’ll put this in terms you can understand.

1) War is hell.
Gen Z, your generation begins around 1997. The oldest of you were, at best, four years old on September 11, 2001. To most of you, who were born after that horrific day, it is a historical event. We on this blog have tried to convey the shock and trauma of that day over the years. I know that the progressive left wants to blame the United States for giving al-Qaeda “cause” for attacking us on 9/11. Does the progressive left also tell you who died that day? Families. Children. People simply going about their every day lives. What did they do to deserve death?

Now think about the numbers of people who were killed in Israel on October 7th. People just going to a concert. Families. Children. People in their own homes, living their every day lives. What did they do to deserve death?

Think about this – no one asked the United States to declare a “ceasefire” on al-Qaeda, or the Taliban (who were hosting them) after 9/11. There was no question of going after them. Why, then, are there calls for Israel to accept a “ceasefire,” when there was a ceasefire in effect before Hamas broke it on October 7th? The United States spent a decade hunting down Osama bin Laden, and yet there are some in Congress calling for a “ceasefire” and “restraint.” This is war. The government of Israel issued a declaration of war on Hamas, which runs the government of Gaza. War is hell.

Unfortunately, innocent people die in war. There has never been a war in the history of the world that has not resulted in innocents being killed, either accidentally or as a result of forcing a surrender. Telling Israel that it cannot target underground tunnels in Gaza, even though there may be a hospital or a school on top of it (which Hamas does to protect themselves, using their own people as human shields), would be the same as telling the Allies during World War II that they could not target the Führerbunker in Berlin, because even though Hitler was there, so were the Goebbels children. War is not a game, even though your generation has been raised on video games that let you play at war. War is not a movie, which I know you have seen plenty of – be they fictional wars, historical wars, or documentaries. War is hell.

2) Israel is fighting to survive, and they have a right to do so.
I know, I know, you’ve been hearing all the chants about “decolonization” and “apartheid” and “stolen land” and other such bullshit. The Jewish people have lived in the area we know today as the state of Israel continuously for more than a millenia. While other military forces and countries have invaded and controlled that area in the past, there has been a Jewish population in Israel for far longer than Islam has even existed – which traces its beginnings to 610 to 613 AD in Mecca. After World War I and the fall of the Ottoman Empire, the British took control of the area, which was then known as the British Mandate of Palestine. The intent, all the way back in 1917, was to give the Jews their own country, with a “two-state solution.” Well, two states were made. One was Israel, which declared independence with the backing of the United Nations in 1948. The other was Transjordan – which is the country you now know today as Jordan. So, what happened? Jordan, ruled by the Hashemite dynasty, refused to accept the Arab Muslims living in the new state of Israel, thus creating a permanent “refugee” status that still exists to this day.

We can skip ahead a bit, and stop at the 2005 withdrawl of all Israelis from Gaza. The Oslo Accords in 1993 had created the framework for a self-governing “Palestinian state” in Gaza. The Israeli army forcibly removed all of its citizens in 2005 from the designated area – the same area that is now so colorfully referred to as “an open-air prison” by some. Hamas was then elected as the government in 2007, and have since then been focused on enriching themselves on the backs of the civilians, and waging war on Israel. On October 7th, Hamas invaded Israel, murdered hundreds and hundreds of people, and took hostages. If either Mexico or Canada had done the same to the United States, it would have resulted in a declaration of war – which is what Israel did. Remember, Hamas is the ELECTED GOVERNMENT in Gaza. Its leaders are currently hiding in luxury in Qatar, mysteriously wealthy while Gazans live in poverty. No country would be expected to simply accept a massacre of civilians with no response. The United States didn’t. Israel shouldn’t, either.

3) Hamas is evil and must lose.
Have you read the Hamas Charter, Gen Z? Do you know what Hamas stands for? What do you think their actual aims are? Here is their spokesman to tell you.

So many of you are parroting Hamas, and you have no idea what they actually stand for. Let me tell you – you won’t like it when you know.


So, Gen Z – why are you supporting a government that would murder your “queer” friends? Why are you supporting a government that says men must control women? Why are you supporting a government that last held an election in 2006, and then seized power completely in 2007? Can you tell me why?

As you can see, Hamas is opposed to all those things you proclaim to value, and yet, you are chanting for their “freedom.” Is it Israel holding the people of Gaza back, or is it Hamas? It seems that all Hamas is focused on is killing Jews and destroying Israel. Is murder, rape, and destruction okay with you?

4) You need to understand evil.
I know that many of you have rejected any kind of organized religion, instead deciding that you are “spiritual,” and can pick and choose what you like, and what to ignore. Gen Z, listen up. There is such a thing as good and evil, and you need to recognize what evil looks like, even if you would rather turn away and pretend that everyone in the world is just like you. For those of you who do believe in God, then you must realize that there is a good and there is an evil.

Tied into this is the notion modern society cannot fathom, that being evil’s existence aside from the flippant assigning of “evil” to anyone or anything deemed potentially ruining the party. Since October 7, 2023, the world has seen brutality and death on a scale unimaginable to the allegedly sophisticated modern mind. The Israel-Hamas War is anything but the bloodless imagery of video games flashing across a screen, imaginary bullets cutting down digital depictions of nonexistent foes. From the war’s beginning, subhuman perversion on Hamas’ part has ravaged humanity on a scale and to a depraved depth hard to envision and even harder to stomach for even the most battle-hardened veteran observers of man’s inhumanity.

It is little wonder that in the face of such barbarism, many have retreated to their preferred variant of lollipop dreams in a cotton candy sky, one in which Hamas’ satanic cruelty and hatred cannot possibly exist and therefore does not exist. Also seeping from society’s sewer are the hardened antisemites whose true gruesome colors are now on full display. In addition, an allegedly more civilized yet equally vacuous resistance to Israel’s effort toward forever ending Hamas in the only fashion it can be terminated, namely killing its members and supporters, emanates from social media stages and corporate political/media stooges bleating for an Israeli-led ceasefire as a legitimate response. Were it not for the desperately unfunny nature of matters, this would be laughable. Envision, if you will, a bully punching you in the nose. You draw your fist back to hit back twice as hard, thus ensuring no further assault. At the sight of this, the bully cries out, “Don’t hit me! No more violence!” This takes place with no assurance save their word alone of the bully abandoning their previous behavior. Does any reasonable person agree to such a relationship? The last person who did so was Neville Chamberlain, and as a quick glance at history’s way reveals, it did not go well for him or Europe.

Evil doesn’t just exist in a history book, as your teachers may have told you. Evil walks among us right now. Evil is the person who celebrates the death of others. It’s an uncomfortable thought, isn’t it?

I promised to explain this to you in terms that you can understand. This is how I explained it to my oldest son, now an adult, who is on the autism spectrum. He has been watching the Marvel Cinematic Universe since he was young. When he asked why innocent people had to die, I reminded him of the scene in the first “Iron Man,” where the Ten Rings terrorists are using women and children as human shields when confronted by Iron Man in his first big “reveal” fight. In the movie, Iron Man uses his advanced technology to target and kill ONLY the terrorists. All the hostages are saved. That movie is fiction, I told him. That technology does not exist. In war, there are casualties and losses. Not everything can be undone with Infinity Stones and a snap of the fingers.

But here is a thought exercise for you, Gen Z. Let us pretend that the Infinity Stones are real, and I have them assembled in the Gauntlet and am ready to snap. I offer you this deal – I snap my fingers, and every single Hamas fighter and leader is instantly gone. No civilian casualties. But Israel survives as a country, and a people. Would you take that deal?

My fear is that too many of you would not accept the survival of Israel. If that is so, then you have chosen sides. And it’s not the side of good. You are the very bloodthirsty racists that you claim your enemies are, and you are willing to accept and celebrate the death of children in order to get what you want. Think about it. For your own sakes.

Featured image: flag of Israel by edu_castro27 via Pixabay, cropped and modified, Pixabay license

Written by

13 Comments
  • Andrew X says:

    You have stated a spectacularly cogent list of facts and logical conclusions regarding these terrifying issues confronting all of us today.

    HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!!!

    You think facts and logic are going to make the slightest dent in people who have been TAUGHT all their lives their feelings trump EVERYTHING else…. that whatever makes them feel bad, forces them to confront their own contradictions, makes them consider that their feelings themselves might be wrong and entirely unjustified….? This to the most emotionally selfish generation ever to walk the earth?

    That’s adorable. It really is.

    • John Shepherd says:

      Conservatives have a problem framing issues so Millenials and Generation Z can understand them. What conservatives need to do is ask “Which side would Hitler support?” We don’t have to speculate as there is photographic evidence. Here is Hitler with the still referred by Palestinian Arabs and the Muslim Brotherhood Amin Al Husseni, Grand Mufti of Jerusalem:

      https://images.app.goo.gl/zU2MX8KzXs5idTtU8

  • John Shepherd says:

    This is the theme song of Generati9n Z.

    https://youtu.be/_tUctFu46_c?si=K93w6AItbhb70OhX

    They said “it can’t happen here “. They were wrong.

  • NTSOG says:

    Theme? Is life for many [immature] Gen Z juveniles actually like living in a sheltered theme park like Fantasyland a la Disney world? Certainly it seems they don’t live in Adventure Land.

  • […] emerging threats, and Unmanned U.S. Navy water drone fires missile in an exercise Victory Girls: Dear Gen Z: We Need To Talk About Israel & Hamas Watts Up With That: California’s EV Conundrums, Court Blocks Pennsylvania from Joining RGGI, and […]

  • Scott says:

    “This takes place with no assurance save their word alone of the bully abandoning their previous behavior.” is the only part of your post I’ll disagree with, because Ham-Ass makes no such assurance, in fact, the only one they do offer is to continue THIER genocide until Israel and Jews worldwide no longer exist..

  • GWB says:

    no one asked the United States to declare a “ceasefire” on al-Qaeda, or the Taliban (who were hosting them) after 9/11
    Oh yes, they did. The same hardcore bunch of anti-Americans successfully got us to not declare war on Islam (or even fundamentalist Islam) but on “terror.”

    War is not a game
    This. And it goes beyond video games. Progressivism insists that war actually be a game – played by professionals on a set-aside field, away from daily life. That way they can lay the blame for death and destruction entirely on the people fighting it and hold themselves aloof from it, thereby signaling their virtue.
    I saw something about “unimaginable things” again (a journalist), in reference to what Israel is doing in Gaza. I replied that they need to shut up and read some history so they understand what Israel is doing is very much on the “nice” side of war.

    A perfect place for this John Stuart Mill quote (again):

    War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things: the decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth a war, is much worse. When a people are used as mere human instruments for firing cannon or thrusting bayonets, in the service and for the selfish purposes of a master, such war degrades a people. A war to protect other human beings against tyrannical injustice; a war to give victory to their own ideas of right and good, and which is their own war, carried on for an honest purpose by their free choice, — is often the means of their regeneration. A man who has nothing which he is willing to fight for, nothing which he cares more about than he does about his personal safety, is a miserable creature who has no chance of being free, unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself. As long as justice and injustice have not terminated their ever-renewing fight for ascendancy in the affairs of mankind, human beings must be willing, when need is, to do battle for the one against the other.

  • GWB says:

    The Jewish people have lived in the area we know today as the state of Israel continuously for more than a millenia.
    Try, more like THREE and a half millennia. Joshua crossed the Jordan in ~1400BC. Despite exiles, there have been some Israelites living there that entire time. Even during the Crusades there were Jews living in Israel. I do not believe Israel has been “Judenfrei” since that 1400BC date.

    Hamas was then elected as the government in 2007
    Note something important about that date, and the 2005 one? They were both before the tenure of the Lightbringer, 0bama. There has been NO “occupation” of Gaza by Israel since before 0bama.

    Remember, Hamas is the ELECTED GOVERNMENT in Gaza.
    That means, for all the Progressive reality-deniers out there, that Israel can legitimately treat the “innocent” “civilians” of Gaza as enemy. There are times and places where they maybe should not treat them as combatants, but they can certainly treat them as enemies. With all that entails.

  • GWB says:

    Hamas is opposed to all those things you proclaim to value
    Cognitive dissonance is not something Progressives handle well. You might trigger a few people with that.
    However, there are TWO values on which Progressives and Muslims agree: Western Civilization must yield to them, and By Any Means Necessary until their religion leads to paradise.

    I know that many of you have rejected any kind of organized religion, instead deciding that you are “spiritual,” and can pick and choose what you like, and what to ignore.
    That’s what they would like to think. But they’re wrong. They canNOT be simply “spiritual” or even secular. They, in rejecting all of those other gods, can have only one recourse: to see themselves as god. This was the first and most successful lie the Progressives cast upon us – that they are not a religion, simply because they reject “mythical” gods. They claim to reject metaphysics and accept only reason – really becoming worshipers of REASON! (as they deify SCIENCE!, while rejecting actual science) and self. Rejecting the community of “organized” religion is really simply stating that you, yourself, will declare what your god is.

    there is a good and there is an evil.
    Keep in mind that you only believe this because you were raised in a society founded on Christianity and not rejecting the observation of human nature over several millennia. If you reject Christianity in its entirety, then you can stand anything as “evil” and anything done against said “evil” is righteous and good.
    Which is a pretty evil standard, really.

    Evil is the person who celebrates the death of others.
    You mean, like “Shout your abortion”? Yeah, I don’t expect people who can argue for the worthlessness of unborn babies to grasp evil when it occurs to the post-born, either. For these folks, there is nothing wrong with killing anyone, as long as the virtue boxes are checked – colonialism, feminism, oppressor/oppressed.

    I snap my fingers, and every single Hamas fighter and leader is instantly gone. No civilian casualties.
    It’s a nice thought, but it wouldn’t work. You know why? Because many of those civilians are accomplices. And many more are being raised to become their replacements. If you snapped your fingers and every single guilty* person in Gaza vanished… I think you would find a few women and one or two men suddenly trying to care for hundreds of mewling infants and NO ONE ELSE.

    (* Not “guilty” in the Christian sense of having sinned, but the specific instance of having supported Hamas or any other terrorist group within Gaza, Lebanon, or the West Bank.)

  • A Reader says:

    It is super rich to be writing to Gen Z when the vast majority of your audience, possibly even all it, are Baby Boomers with a few Gen X thrown in. The comments here basically prove this.

    First of all, yet again it would be so lovely if this author and all the other ones here bothered to do research and learn history. The Geneva Convention, which was long in the process of being ratified and added to, did not add anything about civilians, etc. until 1949, aka after Hitler’s bunker was bombed. So that point is moot. But it is in effect now. So the IDF bombing refugee camps does count. Israel is a signer of the Geneva Convention and has to abide by the rules REGARDLESS of what Hamas does.

    Also, Palestinians aren’t all part of Hamas. So labeling them as such, which this author appears to be doing, is really disingenuous. Perhaps she should remember her own family history after Pearl Harbor which she has written about more than once on this blog. And saying that Hamas was elected is so cute. Forcing your way into power isn’t a real election: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2023/10/was-hamas-elected-to-govern-gaza-george-w-bush-2006-palestinian-election.html
    Not to mention that half of those living under Hamas weren’t even born when they took over.

    Speaking of celebrating the death of others, I think women in Texas who this author once stated that it was “good” to have bounties put on their heads for seeking an abortion, regardless of the reason, would like to have a word…

    This whole post is just an exercise in evangelical Zionism. The author refuses to see Palestinian as people who also have a long history in the region. It may not be as long, but it’s still there. And not all Jews support the right wing propaganda, any more than all Christians do. Jews are not a monolith. There are Jews that fully believe in a two state solution and want to see the Palestinians have a place in the region. This area of the world is also home to Christians, including Palestinian Christians, but never mind them, their skin is the wrong color and they must be terrorist supporters too.

    Multiple things can be true at once, which is something I hope Gen Z can understand:

    1. What happened last month was a terrorist attack and should be condemned, full stop.
    2. Israel does have the right to retaliate, however, they do not have the right to commit war crimes.
    3. Both sides have committed war crimes. Attacking refugee camps is a war crime.
    4. Not all Palestinians are supporters of Hamas, in the same way that not all Germans were Nazis, not all Japanese-Americans supported Japan during WWII, not all Vietnamese were part of the Viet Cong, not all Muslims are supporters of ISIS, and not all Americans are racist xenophobes.

    • GWB says:

      Israel is a signer of the Geneva Convention and has to abide by the rules REGARDLESS of what Hamas does.
      No, actually, it doesn’t. The Geneva Conventions specifically exempt a combatant from compliance if the enemy first violates the accord by doing such things as using civilians as shields, placing weapons on, in or near otherwise exempt civilian facilities, or not wearing a distinct military uniform (in order to blend into civilian populations). They are only beholden to attempt to avoid unnecessary civilian casualties.

      You might try actually reading documents for yourself instead of relying on what your “experts” feed you. (Hint: I was required for years to take Law of Armed Conflict training on an annual basis, as well as actual academic courses in it. I’ve read the actual documents.) Also, there are multiple layers of the Geneva Conventions and other such. Many of them have not been adopted by America or Israel, and are not binding on us. (Hint: it’s because they go well beyond just war doctrine, and unfairly hamper any side abiding by the rules.)

      Both sides have committed war crimes. Attacking refugee camps is a war crime.
      Wrong on both counts. Please direct me to a single war crime Israel has committed. And that second statement doesn’t count, because it’s not a war crime, given the circumstances*. You’re simply spouting the Progressive lies at this point.

      not all Japanese-Americans supported Japan during WWII, not all Vietnamese were part of the Viet Cong
      Both of those are non-sequiturs in the argument you’re making.
      Also, the vast majority of Gazans support Hamas. The vast majority of women and a certain subset of children are active supporters, if not actual participants in action against Israel – acts of war. Also, Hamas is the government of Gaza. Therefore, it IS a war against Gaza not just against miscellaneous “terrorists”. So, just as we bombed Germany to induce surrender, Israel could, if they desired, legitimately bomb all of Gaza to induce their surrender. Period.

      (* The “refugee camps” are not, really. They’re towns. They started as refugee camps in about 1967. They no longer are and only a fool would consider them such. Also, there’s the whole “If it’s a refugee camp, then why are there military headquarters and weapons emplacements here?” bit.)

    • GWB says:

      Not to mention that half of those living under Hamas weren’t even born when they took over.
      So, by that standard our Constitution is obsolete, since no one alive today voted for it?
      Or, are you saying that since Hamas cancelled elections, it’s no longer legitimate? A vast number of countries in the world would like to have a word with you – and you wouldn’t get to talk back about it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe
Become a Victory Girl!

Are you interested in writing for Victory Girls? If you’d like to blog about politics and current events from a conservative POV, send us a writing sample here.
Ava Gardner
gisonboat
rovin_readhead