Previous post
President Trump’s poll numbers creep up regardless of the relentless negative coverage in Pravda media. Democrat approval ratings are still around auto-warranty-telemarketer levels. But advice from the portside Salon to Dems is DOUBLE-DOWN YA WIMPS!
We really are going to need a bigger tub of popcorn.
What Democrats have here is a failure to communicate — and that failure may prove fatal, not just for the party, but for American democracy itself.
RHEEEE! If Democrats don’t control everything it AIN’T “REAL” DEMOCRACY!!!
disillusioned Democrats have been searching for someone or something — anyone or anything — to solve their entrenched messaging and branding failures.
Branding? Democrats who did nothing but relentless sprint left since Jesus Obama called for the fundamental changing of America feel their drubbing was do to marketing?
Not enough Brat?
A recent poll by the Wall Street Journal found only 33% of voters hold a favorable view of Democrats, with 63% expressing an unfavorable view of the party — the most unpopular Democrats have been in 35 years of WSJ polling.
But but but, branding, amirite?
Ok, this is just Salon’s resident auntie, Chauncey DeVega, seething beta-dude of pallor who always finds new ways of bringing the cringe to the written page. But he certainly isn’t wrong in pointing out that Democrats have been soundly rejected by rational American adults. So much so that some Democrat candidates are trying to hide their blue-donkey identity with the fig-leaf of “Independent”.
Politico’s Andrew Howard reports that former Democrats Brian Bengs in South Dakota (Trump +29 in 2024) and Todd Achilles in Idaho (Trump +36) are joining former Democrat Dan Osborn of Nebraska (Trump +20) to run for senator as self-declared independents, with no credible Democrat in the race. (snip)
Why are these Democrats, some in states such as South Dakota and Nebraska that have reelected Democratic senators in recent years, shunning the Democratic label? Most likely because, in a country of increased straight-ticket voting, they believe the Democratic label is political poison.
OH NOES! Anyway, Chauncey jumps back on the marketing excuse.
Since 2008, Democratic support among working-class white men has dropped by 30 percent. And in the 2024 election, Trump was able to make inroads with working-class Black and Latino men.
Part of the issue, according to Reece Peck, a communications scholar and author of “Fox Populism: Branding Conservatism as Working Class,” comes down to divergent social identities and language. He described Democrats as being centered on upper middle-class “hyper-educationed Americans” who “place immense value on language.”
Yet as Chauncey further explains, and the whole of Salon proves every day, this so-called valuing of language isn’t about communication but manipulation. It’s the use of words and images to convey a narrative to support the Left’s ideology, regardless of facts. If the foundational values of ‘Conservatism’ are being embraced by the working class, it has little to do with branding.
“The fatal flaw is that Democrats often assume this class-specific cultural fixation is widely shared across the broader electorate,” Peck said. “In contrast, working-class Americans tend to approach language more contextually. They often interpret statements in good faith and prioritize the intention behind a message more than the exact wording — unlike many in the professional class, who insist that intention is irrelevant.”
Again … if intention in the message is irrelevant, then communication is nothing more than a game of Who is The Biggest Manipulator?
Of course, as Chauncey continues to whine, he cannot see his own adherence to using language untethered to reality
But while the Democrats keep conducting autopsies and churning out plans to be authentic, curse more and find the next Joe Rogan, Trump and his MAGA supporters are rapidly destroying the country’s democratic life. In the face of these threats and autocratic actions, Democrats need to return to fundamentals in their messaging.
A brand is a form of emotional identification between a person and a product. In modern marketing and advertising, it is also an extension of a person’s identity. At its core, a brand can provide a type of “team” that stands to make people feel less isolated and lonely.
In politics, this means distilling a complex message into something emotional that has a direct connection to a person or group. This is especially critical given how political scientists and other experts have consistently shown that the average American is imagistic, easily distracted and manipulated, lacks an in-depth understanding of public policy and history, and has a hard time distinguishing between facts and mistruths.
And there you have it. Leftism’s hierarchal template on naked display. The MAD Man stars of 20th Century corporate advertising were not this bigoted about their audience. But here you have Chauncey off-handedly dismissing the majority of American citizens as drooling morons who can’t help but vote against the Cool Kids who deserve to be in charge.
Middle-school mean girls will run your life and you will like it!
Far be it from me to discourage Chauncey or the other scribblers at Salon (or WaPo or NYSlimes or even the Left-captured WSJ) from continuing down the path of prioritizing branding over substance. We know every squeal about racism, sexism, Islamophobia, transphobia, yadda yadda yadda is never actually about issues.
“The issue is never the issue, the issue is always about the Revolution.”
Indeed.
UPDATE: Welcome Instapundit readers!
featured image, cropped and modified, Adobe Stock standard license
I think Chauncey’s description of “the average American “ fits Ivy League undergrads and faculty pretty well. Meanwhile, the donks need to realize that if what they’re selling is a pasture pie, it’s not going to make any difference if they call it chocolate mousse. Sixty years ago the Democratic Party was able to cut itself loose from its segregationist wing and it survived that. Now they need to do the same with their lunatics on the left. It will be a hard break for some but it will get them where they need to be.
“But I’ve bought into the glabal project so thoroughly, it MUST be the salvation of the people of the world!
If only we could REASON with it.
-them!
Them.
If only we could reason with them…”
Is he any relation to “Chauncey Gardner? It would explain quite a lot.
“Sixty years ago the Democratic Party was able to cut itself loose from its segregationist wing and it survived that. ”
They didn’t cut loose anything. (Robert Byrd, Joe Biden, and LBJ are Exhibits A, B, C). They simply started lying and relied on information control including a carefully curated stable of “civil rights leaders” to get them past it. Now, with the rise of the alternate media, they can’t keep the lies hidden any more.
Our good friends on the left have waxed apoplectic over the Sydney Sweeney American Eagle ads precisely because they appeal to normal men, who like pretty women, and normal women, who want to appeal to men.
The latest ad appeared on my Facebook feeds this morning, in which Miss Sweeney was going over what’s hot or not, and she concluded with men who can change the oil in their own vehicles as being hot. Can you picture any of the males who work at Salon as being able to change the oil in their cars?
The soy-boys who write for Salon wouldn’t dream of even trying to attempt such a thing, but are low-key ashamed of the fact that they can’t, and most of them understand that if they ever did get a girlfriend, she’d wind up cheating on them with a guy who can work with his hands.
I believe most of those guys couldn’t start a gas lawn mower. God forbid changing oil or a flat tire. They might break a nail for gawdsakes.
Salon – The Dems need to figure out why people have turned away from their party.
Salon (a few paragraphs later) – voters are stupid little children, and have no grasp of the issues.
Gotta polish that turd to a HIGH LUSTROUS SHEEN!
Since the era of the “Reagan Democrats”, the Democratic party’s contempt for the white working class — and, increasingly, the male working class regardless of race — has become more and more open. And, crying “autocracy!!” when your political opponents implement policies after winning an election has a long and bipartisan history.
“the average American is imagistic, easily distracted and manipulated, lacks an in-depth understanding of public policy and history, and has a hard time distinguishing between facts and mistruths.”
In my experience, this is absolutely true generally speaking, especially of people under 40, regardless of how they vote. The majority of them are phone-addicted, and because of the state of our country and public schools, few of them have much understanding of history or a desire to learn about it. Booooooring. Their understanding of the world largely comes from social media, Instagram Reels, and snippets they see in the MSM. This is a big part of how idiot, evil, far-left Dems keep winning enough elections to remain relevant. Our grandparents’ generation would’ve long ago kicked these Marxists to the curb.
dems have turned marxist. Authoritarian to their core and want/DEMAND compliance without regard to whether their policies make sense, deliver and societal benefit.
People wanna be left alone. Republicans largely grasp this fact.
I’ve been following politics for years and the Democrats, when they lose, always have the same line, “We didn’t get our message out.” I can’t count all the times I’ve heard that but I do know I’ve never heard them admit that perhaps, just perhaps, they might have the wrong message.
Hubristic narcissists are never wrong.
“Trump and his MAGA supporters are rapidly destroying the country’s democratic life. In the face of these threats and autocratic actions, Democrats need to return to fundamentals in their messaging.”
They live in a world of their own imagination. They are certain Trump is tearing down the Constitution, acting unlawfully and having innocent moms and kids abducted and disappeared off the streets. We know none of that is real but they have their narrative and their whole belief system falls apart if they question it.
Ask them to point out some specific laws he’s broken and they’re at a loss. Ask them what Biden and Kamala accomplished they give you a blank stare. They take pride in how much they know but like Reagan said so much of what they know isn’t so.
“We know none of that is real” and so does their leadership. Don’t give them a pass on knowing dishonesty.
We lost – not fair
Like him or not Trump has authenticity – sometimes I agree with some times not – but he’s not pretending to be something he’s not –
but what drives me crazy is he can never let it go – now he wants to pick a fight with the lady from the bureau of economic data? Just let it go – she wins just getting the publicity – give it a rest
What Mr. (I presume on its preferred pronoun) DeVaginea means to say is that democrats must LIE HARDER! It has been the democrat standard electoral ploy to present a leftist candidate who lies through his/her/its teeth about everything in order to get elected, then once safely in office, to implement the standard leftist program. He is convinced this is the key to democrat success and it may be, unless the electorate has wised up to the bait-and-switch tactics.
Darlene, Jeff Goldstein has been exposing the “intentionalism” lie for as long as we’ve known him. I think that deserves a mention, if only so people are made aware of how long some have been fighting it.
LOL – “hyper-educationed Americans”. This is the primary flaw in the DNA of these pretentious scolds. They think they are smarter than everybody else; even though they are perpetually wrong and misinformed on any topic you can think of. “hyper-educationed/ spell much?/wrong, covid/wrong. more than 2 sexes/wrong, Russian collusion/wrong, President butt head’s cognitive decline/wrong, cops are the problem/wrong, being born white predisposes a person to being racist/wrong, reciprocal tariffs will tank the economy/wrong, …… Pick any topic and these hyper-educated morons will be on the wrong side. This is what happens when you conflate going to a hyper-partisan college as getting an education.
“the average American is imagistic, easily distracted and manipulated, lacks an in-depth understanding of public policy and history, and has a hard time distinguishing between facts and mistruths.”
This is unfortunately very true. Far too many Americans under 40 are phone-addicted and get their views on current events from social media, Tik Tok, Instagram Reels, and MSM headlines. Thanks to our failed school system, they were never taught history, nor do they care to learn. Booooooring. In order to compete, we on the right are forced to battle for their allegiance in that arena, but ignorance is a very shaky foundation upon which to maintain a society.
As a branding expert in the private sector what I find slightly amusing here is that even the definition of branding they are using is outdated, wrong, and misapplied. I would be willing to wager that the branding consultant they brought in for this drivel specializes in branding low consideration packaged goods like Cocoa Pops, not high-consideration durable goods like cars. The “brand is just a communications question” model of brand building was never that accurate for anything but the most trivial of low consideration purchases. The underlying product has always mattered a great deal more than communications in building a durable brand. Failing brands have always required a significant update in product, packaging and business model to be successfully revitalized. I’m 100% confident that their rebrand will fail because its premises are flawed from the very start. This does not mean that they won’t regain power, however, because the coming financial crisis will sweep them back in to power despite all of their lunacy. They will draw the wrong conclusions (again) when this happens. The Beatings will continue until morale improves.
[…] doubling down on wacko ideas is a good idea? It DOES seem a bit, uh, […]
23 Comments