Rolling Stone UVA Story Is Epic Failure For Journalism And Rape Victims

On Friday it was reported here at Victory Girls and around the world that Rolling Stone magazine issued a retraction of sorts on the “A Rape on Campus” story written by Sabrina Rubin Erdely. Why was it only sort of a retraction? When you take a closer look, readers will realize that Rolling Stone made it clear in their statement that neither the magazine nor Erdely are to blame for the story being wrong. Perhaps they are hoping the story will go away.

x-la_nn_uva_141205.nbcnews-video-reststate-800

Well guess what, this story and their role in it isn’t going away. Rolling Stone and Sabrina Erdely have served up two epic failures with one stroke of the pen. The first failure is their disregard for one of the all important tenants of good factual journalism. TRUST BUT VERIFY. Instead Erdely and Rolling Stone decided to run a sensational rather than fact-based story. However, due to in-depth reporting by T. Rees Shapiro and Erik Wemple of the Washington Post and others, it is becoming clear that the facts of the case are nearly if not completely different from the account written in Rolling Stone. Erik Wemple writes:

“For the sake of Rolling Stone’s reputation, Sabrina Rubin Erdely had better be the country’s greatest judge of character.”

Sabrina_Erdely2012

Sabrina had an agenda and the veracity of Jackie’s account didn’t matter. Differences in Jackie’s story includes identifying the wrong man, changing certain circumstances of her story, not reporting the attack because friends might lose party privileges at the fraternity, and having advocates start doubting all she described. Furthermore, Shapiro writes:

Jackie’s story empowered many women to speak publicly about attacks on them, but it also immediately raised questions about the decisions Jackie made that evening — not going to a hospital or reporting the alleged crime to police or the school — while some expressed doubt about her story altogether.

The above are questions ANY journalist worth his or her salt should’ve asked before determining if this was a story worth pursuing. If Jackie had suffered the injuries she described, why isn’t there a medical report? Why didn’t she report this to the campus or the local police? Why didn’t her friends or the campus advocates report this to the university? Why didn’t Erdely ask those questions? Why didn’t Rolling Stone ask Erdely about it? I can tell you why. Because Sabrina didn’t care to truly examine Jackie’s character or veracity, and Rolling Stone decided that sensational garbage was better than the facts.

family flag
Subscribe
250
Become a Victory Girl!

Are you interested in writing for Victory Girls? If you’d like to blog about politics and current events from a conservative POV, send us a writing sample here.

Sunday Morning Cafe Cocktails

https://victorygirlsblog.com/sunday-morning-cafe-cocktails-216/

Mimosa, Bloody Mary, nice flute of champagne — or maybe a favorite tipple in your coffee. Make yourself one and join me at our own Algonquin Round...

Continue reading

The post Sunday Mornin

Making Monkeys of Their Audience: Racial Bias in the Corporate Press

https://victorygirlsblog.com/press-bias-monkey-noises/

The corporate press is deliberately feeding its audience a false version of reality by ignoring stories of black-on-white violence and elevating reports of “racism” against black…

Hakeem Jeffries Will Be Speaker By Default, And The DSA Is Mad

https://victorygirlsblog.com/hakeem-jeffries-will-be-speaker-by-default-and-the-dsa-is-mad/

The DSA is going to learn a very important lesson very quickly within the House of Representatives – you don’t rock the boat when you are told...

Continue reading

The post Hakeem Jeffries W

FAA Lifts Ground Stop, Fingers Point To Blame

https://victorygirlsblog.com/faa-lifts-ground-stop-fingers-point-to-blame/

Yesterday was not a good day to be on a plane, in an airport, or part of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The FAA announced the unprecedented...

Continue reading

The post FAA Lift

Ava Gardner
gisonboat
Victory Girls
rovin_readhead